Sunday, June 3, 2007

Just the Numbers: Week 22

THE NUMBERS

Fred Thompson moves up, Giuliani moves down. Romney has not lost any strength.

THE STRATEGIES

I wondered aloud here about the possibility of a third-party or independent candidacy. The "field" option has been very slowly rising over the past weeks. The move seems not to be a blip any longer.

Richardson seems like a more likely VP candidate, if one is betting on Clinton, yes?

Next PresidentPr (%)Chg Wk.bid-ask
CLINTON(H)36.6-1.63%
OBAMA17.20.21%
THOMPSON(F)11.13.91%
GIULIANI1101%
McCAIN102.630%
ROMNEY9.80.812%
GORE80.61%
2007 Week 22: Health policy speeches; Fred Thompson moves toward candidacy.
GOP NomineePr (%)Chg Wk.bid-ask
GIULIANI24.2-3.14%
ROMNEY2300%
THOMPSON(F)24.62.71%
MCCAIN17.1-0.94%
GINGRICH2.5-0.44%
HUCKABEE2-0.25%
PAUL2.20.918%
DEM NomineePr (%)Chg Wk.bid-ask
CLINTON51-0.11%
OBAMA27.5-11%
GORE10.50.82%
EDWARDS7.2-0.11%
RICHRDSN2.3-0.64%
BIDEN0.50n.m.
CLARK0.50n.m.
SenatePr (%)Chg Wk.bid-ask
DEM8006%
GOP15053%
Next ExecutivePr (%)Chg Wk.bid-ask
DEM55.1-0.73%
GOP41.5-0.20%
OTH3.50.96%
DEM VP NomineePr (%)Chg Wk.bid-ask
OBAMA27.50.520%
RICHARDSON16.2085%
GORE121.925%
BAYH10250%
EDWARDS9.3060%
CLARK7.70.1212%
NUNN5.2083%

src: intrade.com; bid-ask are not points, but spread as a percentage of the bid. Polls comparison, via ealClearPolitics.
IMPORTANT DISCLAIMER: this is just an informational note and not a solicitation or recommendation to buy or sell securities and there is no guarantee implied and people can lose all money on all investments. Numbers are believed to be correct, but do your own math and make your own conclusions or consult with an advisor before making any decisions.

Sunday, May 27, 2007

Just the Numbers: Week 21

THE NUMBERS

Romney moved up sharply in the week, mostly at the expense of McCain.

Fred Thompson continues to run a solid non-campaign campaign.

Next PresidentPr (%)Chg Wk.bid-ask
CLINTON(H)38.2-0.61%
OBAMA170.33%
GIULIANI11-1.127%
ROMNEY938%
GORE7.4-0.75%
McCAIN7.4-4.755%
THOMPSON(F)7.2-0.811%
2007 Week 21: McCain and Romney trade barbs; Hillary gives first major policy speech (on health care); Supplemental GWOT bill pulls Dems to left on Iraq; Bush warns of al-qaeda at commencement address.
GOP NomineePr (%)Chg Wk.bid-ask
GIULIANI27.3-0.90%
MCCAIN18-8.18%
ROMNEY234.21%
THOMPSON(F)21.95.64%
GINGRICH2.9-1.17%
HAGEL1.2-1.1n.m.
HUCKABEE2.2-0.15%
DEM NomineePr (%)Chg Wk.bid-ask
CLINTON51.1-0.10%
OBAMA28.50.26%
GORE9.70.13%
EDWARDS7.3-0.11%
RICHRDSN2.90.73%
BIDEN0.50n.m.
CLARK0.50n.m.
SenatePr (%)Chg Wk.bid-ask
DEM80-16%
GOP15053%
Next ExecutivePr (%)Chg Wk.bid-ask
DEM55.8-0.22%
GOP41.7-0.80%
OTH2.60.34%
DEM VP NomineePr (%)Chg Wk.bid-ask
OBAMA27127%
RICHARDSON16.20.1104%
GORE10.13.148%
EDWARDS9.3061%
BAYH83.888%
CLARK7.60229%
NUNN5.2092%

src: intrade.com; bid-ask are not points, but spread as a percentage of the bid. Polls comparison, via ealClearPolitics.
IMPORTANT DISCLAIMER: this is just an informational note and not a solicitation or recommendation to buy or sell securities and there is no guarantee implied and people can lose all money on all investments. Numbers are believed to be correct, but do your own math and make your own conclusions or consult with an advisor before making any decisions.

First peek at the 2008 Senate races. These contracts have very little traded volume, currently:

DEM SenatorsPr (%)Chg Wk.bid-ask
Louisiana-Landrieu, Mary L. (D-LA)55018%
South Dakota-Johnson, Tim (D-SD)75013%
Iowa-Harkin, Tom (D-IA)80013%
Montana-Baucus, Max (D-MT)80013%
New Jersey-Lautenberg, Frank R. (D-NJ)80013%
Arkansas-Pryor, Mark L. (D-AR)85012%
Illinois-Durbin, Richard (D-IL)85012%
West Virginia-Rockefeller, John D., IV (D-WV)900n.m.
Delaware-Biden, Joseph R., Jr. (D-DE)900n.m.
Rhode Island-Reed, Jack (D-RI)900n.m.
Michigan-Levin, Carl (D-MI)900n.m.
Massachusetts-Kerry, John F. (D-MA)900n.m.
GOP SenatorsPr (%)Chg Wk.bid-ask
Colorado-Allard, Wayne (R-CO)40025%
New Hampshire-Sununu, John E. (R-NH)55018%
Virginia-Warner, John (R-VA)60017%
Minnesota-Coleman, Norm (R-MN)62013%
Maine-Collins, Susan M. (R-ME)65015%
Oregon-Smith, Gordon H. (R-OR)70014%
Oklahoma-Inhofe, James M. (R-OK)80013%
Nebraska-Hagel, Chuck (R-NE)80013%
Georgia-Chambliss, Saxby (R-GA)80013%
Tennessee-Alexander, Lamar (R-TN)80013%
North Carolina-Dole, Elizabeth (R-NC)80013%
Idaho-Craig, Larry E. (R-ID)80013%
Kentucky-McConnell, Mitch (R-KY)85012%
Alaska-Stevens, Ted (R-AK)85012%
South Carolina-Graham, Lindsey (R-SC)85012%
New Mexico-Domenici, Pete V. (R-NM)85012%
Texas-Cornyn, John (R-TX)900n.m.
Wyoming-Enzi, Michael B. (R-WY)900n.m.
Mississippi-Cochran, Thad (R-MS)900n.m.
Alabama-Sessions, Jeff (R-AL)900n.m.
Kansas-Roberts, Pat (R-KS)900n.m.

Sunday, May 20, 2007

NYC is Turning into a Museum

In his latest provocative thesis, Professor Niall Ferguson suggests the impending doom of New York as a center, just as Venice was turned into a museum in centuries past.

It's not a completely clear thesis. It appears attached to job outsourcing, but not clearly which ones, except maybe financial deals getting done outside of NYC. Some weight is given to a resurgent Asia.

The relative depth and breadth of U.S. consumer markets and the generally stable political environment favor a continuation of the U.S., even under a "great re-convergence". It's not an either/or.

What could happen, however, is the that U.S. policy makers fail to recognize the shifts, besotted of past days of that rare combination of political and financial prowess, and thereby fail to adequately protect the U.S. economy from the pending realignments in economic strength.

In other words, it's not just America's military role that could tip the scales one way or the other. It could be a cultural milieu that fails to adapt. The experience with Japan in the late 1980s and early 1990s is perhaps instructive of how difficult those adaptations can truly be, both in divination and in implementation.

Venice on the Hudson

Saturday, May 19, 2007

Just the Numbers: Week 20

THE NUMBERS

Clinton has moved up sizeably in the rankings, with a strong bid even this week (check out graph via link). McCain's rebound is complete. (I haven't been tracking it carefully, but the volume/interest in the presidential contract has ticked up in the weeks since the last report).

On technical matters, the bid side of the market for the GOP nomination has firmed considerably. Any number of factors might account for this, including sheer buying interest. It may also reflect a sense that no new entrants to the race are likely, beyond those already being ranked, and/or that dropouts among the main candidates are increasingly less likely.

THE STRATEGIES

The prospect of an "independent" doesn't seem much in the numbers, apart from a blip in the 'OTH' category for the party of the next president. Aside from that, there may be something to looking at potential VP contracts (see last table), even though the volume in these contracts is very low and the bid-ask spreads, huge.

Gore, Edwards, Biden and Clark continue to represent 17% of the probability for the Dem nomination. Costs probably prevent bets against on Biden/Clark, but betting against a successful Gore or Edwards run to the tape still has legs, I'd estimate. Another way to bet against is to pick the set of winners (this can reduce trading costs). If one of the top two wins, Obama or Clinton, the payoff is 20% (but the payoff period may linger beyond super Tuesday...).

Hagel, Gingrich, Huckabee and Brownback represent just 9% of the probability for the GOP nomination. Brownback is out of it, but the others continue to offer prospects for betting against, perhaps even including trading costs. The top three (Romney, McCain, Giuliani) will pay off 28% against the field, which is more than the you can get on the Dem side.

Next PresidentPr (%)Chg Wk.bid-ask
CLINTON(H)38.814.58%
OBAMA16.7-5.23%
GIULIANI12.1-2.944%
McCAIN12.10.122%
GORE8.1-0.11%
THOMPSON(F)8-211%
ROMNEY6-1.243%
2007 Week 20: GOP Candidates debate in South Carolina with post debate commentary largely about Ron Paul and FOX News continuing to press 'ticking bomb' as germane to general U.S. counterterrorism policy.
GOP NomineePr (%)Chg Wk.bid-ask
GIULIANI28.2-2.64%
MCCAIN26.15.85%
ROMNEY18.83.46%
THOMPSON(F)16.32.11%
GINGRICH40.92%
HAGEL2.3030%
HUCKABEE2.304%
DEM NomineePr (%)Chg Wk.bid-ask
CLINTON51.23.41%
OBAMA28.3-2.71%
GORE9.6-1.84%
EDWARDS7.4-0.27%
RICHRDSN2.2-0.49%
BIDEN0.50n.m.
CLARK0.50n.m.
SenatePr (%)Chg Wk.bid-ask
DEM8115%
GOP15033%
Next ExecutivePr (%)Chg Wk.bid-ask
DEM56-0.50%
GOP42.5-0.30%
OTH2.31.613%

DEM VP NomineePr (%)Chg Wk.bid-ask
OBAMA262.944%
RICHARDSON16.1-0.1104%
EDWARDS9.34.361%
CLARK7.67.6229%
GORE74.4-100%
NUNN5.2092%
CLINTON(H)5060%

* "Chg Wk" is measured since last report, Week 17.
src: intrade.com; bid-ask are not points, but spread as a percentage of the bid. Polls comparison, via ealClearPolitics.
IMPORTANT DISCLAIMER: this is just an informational note and not a solicitation or recommendation to buy or sell securities and there is no guarantee implied and people can lose all money on all investments. Numbers are believed to be correct, but do your own math and make your own conclusions or consult with an advisor before making any decisions.

Saturday, April 28, 2007

Just the Numbers: Week 17

THE NUMBERS

Not too much change in the numbers, except that Gore remains remarkably well bid. The races haven't widened or narrowed appreciably (most of the changes in the period include changes in the bid-ask, rather than shifts among the candidates).

THE STRATEGIES

I've been starting to think about scenarios in which an independent candidate runs, including what might happen if McCain were to do a Joe Lieberman (not sure he'd have the financial support to do that).

The strategy outlined a while back gave back ground, completely on the democratic side, largely as Gore picked up ground rather than losing it.

The entry point to a short strategy on Fred Thompson, which I thought might be on near the date of his announcement as a candidate, may have passed. The more Guiliani stands up to the ongoing vetting, the less likely that Thompson will be a significant runner, "the insurance candidate", perhaps.


Next PresidentPr (%)Chg Wk.bid-ask
CLINTON(H)24.30.38%
OBAMA21.92.40%
GIULIANI15-117%
McCAIN12013%
THOMPSON(F)107.715%
GORE8.20.444%
ROMNEY7.2-0.68%
2007 Week 17: Dems hold their first debate (Hilary reported to do well); McCain makes news on Daily Show with John Stewart; Petreus in Washington with early reports on Baghdad Security Plan.; Senate/House vote timetable on Iraq.
GOP NomineePr (%)Chg Wk.bid-ask
GIULIANI30.8-2.24%
MCCAIN20.31.11%
THOMPSON(F)14.2-1.411%
ROMNEY15.4-2.31%
GINGRICH3.10.13%
HAGEL2.3-0.74%
HUCKABEE2.30.44%
DEM NomineePr (%)Chg Wk.bid-ask
CLINTON47.8-0.30%
OBAMA311.54%
GORE11.42.13%
EDWARDS7.6-0.61%
RICHRDSN2.6-0.84%
CLARK0.50n.m.
BIDEN0.50.2n.m.
SenatePr (%)Chg Wk.bid-ask
DEM8026%
GOP15033%
Next ExecutivePr (%)Chg Wk.bid-ask
DEM56.501%
GOP42.800%
OTH0.70.5n.m.

src: intrade.com; bid-ask are not points, but spread as a percentage of the bid. Polls comparison, via RealClearPolitics.
IMPORTANT DISCLAIMER: this is just an informational note and not a solicitation or recommendation to buy or sell securities and there is no guarantee implied and people can lose all money on all investments. Numbers are believed to be correct, but do your own math and make your own conclusions or consult with an advisor before making any decisions.

Saturday, April 14, 2007

Just the Numbers: Week 15

THE NUMBERS

Fred Thompson drops. Gore suprisingly strong.

THE STRATEGIES

Nothing new this week. Old strategies remain unchanged.

Next PresidentPr (%)Chg Wk.bid-ask
CLINTON(H)24-0.713%
OBAMA19.5-0.513%
GIULIANI160.26%
McCAIN12-0.715%
ROMNEY7.80.88%
GORE7.801%
EDWARDS4063%
2007 Week 15: F. Thompson discloses cancer; McCain gives much talked about Iraq speech; Newt debates Kerry on climate; Bill Richardson on mission to North Korea.
GOP NomineePr (%)Chg Wk.bid-ask
GIULIANI333.92%
MCCAIN19.21.31%
ROMNEY17.71.21%
THOMPSON(F)15.6-4.46%
HAGEL30.617%
GINGRICH3-0.913%
HUCKABEE1.90.2n.m.
DEM NomineePr (%)Chg Wk.bid-ask
CLINTON48.10.10%
OBAMA29.5-2.51%
GORE9.30.94%
EDWARDS8.211%
RICHRDSN3.4-0.23%
CLARK0.50n.m.
BIDEN0.3-0.3n.m.
SenatePr (%)Chg Wk.bid-ask
DEM7814%
GOP15-333%
Next ExecutivePr (%)Chg Wk.bid-ask
DEM56.501%
GOP42.8-0.20%
OTH0.20.1n.m.
src: intrade.com; bid-ask are not points, but spread as a percentage of the bid. Polls comparison, via ealClearPolitics.
IMPORTANT DISCLAIMER: this is just an informational note and not a solicitation or recommendation to buy or sell securities and there is no guarantee implied and people can lose all money on all investments. Numbers are believed to be correct, but do your own math and make your own conclusions or consult with an advisor before making any decisions.

Tuesday, April 10, 2007

Remember the magical "Ownership Society"?

Despite much enthusiasm for the purported efficiency-alignments of the "ownership society", I haven't seen much support cropping up for Sam Zell's reported proposal to take the Tribune companies private using an ESOP plan.


Becker-Posner tow a hard line on ESOPs, in general. Others, like Mankiw, probably won't say, one way or the other. Becker might include studies that look at significant non-ESOP ownership, including restricted-stock and incentive-stock option plans.


I think that the truth is that employee ownership within companies can be a powerful force, if and when other incentives are aligned within the firm such that people feel that they will 'unlock wealth' by this or that action. There are cultural aspects to 'ownership' within a company. If managers tolerate each other running departments as fiefdoms whose inefficiencies and brand-consuming behaviors (rather than brand-building) accrue to their benefit, then putting ownership interests in the lower echelons will probably just create conflict.


Sam Zell is no chump. It's an experiment worth watching, IMO.

Saturday, April 7, 2007

Just the Numbers: Week 14

THE NUMBERS

Obama and Thompson are the moving-uppers in the week. Clinton holds, but Giuliani skids (just over nine points).

The GOP race widens even further, with the top three losing an eye-popping 11% of the overall distribution in the last week.

THE STRATEGIES

The strategy outlined three weeks or so ago turned up another 1.3 points (6.2 so far), before trading costs, as Al Gore's skid accelerated in the week.

It stands to reason that there is going to be some further dramatic shake out on the GOP side, unless that you believe that Giuliani, Thompson, McCain, and Romney will dead-heat it all the way to super Tuesday. The big re-sort, barring further vetting issues, might be the Iowa straw polls in August. But here is what Zogby printed in the last week, based on his telphone polls

Pollster John Zogby: “There are two clear front–runners in this Republican race. The fact the race is pretty tight here in Iowa makes New Hampshire even more important as this race develops. There are two big questions surrounding this race – who is the alternative to step into the top tier should one of these two falter, and who will be The Great Conservative Candidate?

This suggests to me that if you want to play for big returns on the GOP side, you have to make a decision fairly soon about whether it is Giuliani or McCain that is going to go the distance to super Tuesday.

That's too hard a call for my simple mind. Instead, I continue to want to make a bet against F. Thompson, just waiting for the right point. I think he is pretty late to the game.


Next PresidentPr (%)Chg Wk.bid-ask
CLINTON(H)24.7013%
OBAMA202.725%
GIULIANI15.8-2.720%
McCAIN12.7-0.59%
GORE7.8-0.21%
ROMNEY7-0.220%
EDWARDS4063%
2007 Week 14: Fundraising figures come out: Dems ahead, but Romney war-chest strong, Obama proves, McCain lags; Tommy Thompson announces on ABC's "This Week"; Giuliani confirms prior view that a just implementation of the law implies poor women cannot be completely cut out from medical prcedures, including abortion; McCain makes surreal walkabout in Baghdad.
GOP NomineePr (%)Chg Wk.bid-ask
GIULIANI29.1-9.23%
MCCAIN17.9-2.23%
ROMNEY16.50.23%
THOMPSON(F)205.49%
HAGEL2.40.225%
GINGRICH3.90.53%
HUCKABEE1.70.7n.m.
DEM NomineePr (%)Chg Wk.bid-ask
CLINTON48-1.30%
OBAMA325.61%
GORE8.4-2.215%
EDWARDS7.2-0.68%
RICHRDSN3.6-0.23%
BIDEN0.60.2n.m.
CLARK0.50n.m.
SenatePr (%)Chg Wk.bid-ask
DEM7705%
GOP18328%
Next ExecutivePr (%)Chg Wk.bid-ask
DEM56.50.51%
GOP430.20%
OTH0.1-0.8n.m.

src: intrade.com; bid-ask are not points, but spread as a percentage of the bid. Polls comparison, via RealClearPolitics.
IMPORTANT DISCLAIMER: this is just an informational note and not a solicitation or recommendation to buy or sell securities and there is no guarantee implied and people can lose all money on all investments. Numbers are believed to be correct, but do your own math and make your own conclusions or consult with an advisor before making any decisions.

Saturday, March 31, 2007

2008 Just the Numbers: Week 13

THE NUMBERS

The GOP race continued to widen, with the jump-up of Thompson in the rankings. Clinton moved ahead just a little more and Edwards recovered some of the ground lost in the prior week. (Thompson is not yet included on the Presidential contract).

THE STRATEGIES

Huckabee fell sharply in the week, and other small hopefuls slid as well, including Hagel and Brownback, but just by tenths. All told, the strategy outlined two weeks ago added another 1%, before trading costs.

The Thompson jump-up must be instructive to Newt Gingrich, who has yet to generate excitement like that.


Next PresidentPr (%)Chg Wk.bid-ask
CLINTON(H)24.711%
GIULIANI18.5-1.519%
OBAMA17.3-1.113%
McCAIN13.21.112%
GORE80.51%
ROMNEY7.20.110%
EDWARDS4050%
2007 Week 13: Clinton/Obama in front of unions; Giuliani vetting reaches Kerik, views on his wife's role; McCain mistakenly calls some Baghdad neighborhoods "safe"; Kyle Sampson indicates AG's statements "not accurate"; Dobson not so humbly informs the Nation that Thompson is not a Christian, a hurricane of fundraising.
GOP NomineePr (%)Chg Wk.bid-ask
GIULIANI38.3-2.21%
MCCAIN20.102%
ROMNEY16.3-0.22%
THOMPSON(F)14.64.520%
HAGEL2.2-0.127%
GINGRICH3.40.132%
HUCKABEE1-1.8n.m.
DEM NomineePr (%)Chg Wk.bid-ask
CLINTON49.32.30%
OBAMA26.4-37%
GORE10.6-0.11%
EDWARDS7.815%
RICHRDSN3.8-0.65%
CLARK0.50.2n.m.
BIDEN0.40n.m.
SenatePr (%)Chg Wk.bid-ask
DEM7705%
GOP15-2.553%
Next ExecutivePr (%)Chg Wk.bid-ask
DEM56-0.10%
GOP42.80.20%
OTH0.9-0.3n.m.

src: intrade.com; bid-ask are not points, but spread as a percentage of the bid.
IMPORTANT DISCLAIMER: this is just an informational note and not a solicitation or recommendation to buy or sell securities and there is no guarantee implied and people can lose all money on all investments. Numbers are believed to be correct, but do your own math and make your own conclusions or consult with an advisor before making any decisions.

Sunday, March 25, 2007

Science of Mind Study Pierces Media Veil

The LA Times covers a story from scientific researchers, who have been able to work with a few people with damage to the VMPC. As with most studies of its kind, the results are fascinating, raising all kinds of questions about what it means to be human in some ways:

The ventromedial prefrontal cortex [VMPC] processes feelings of empathy, shame, compassion and guilt. Damage to this part of the brain, which occupies a small region in the forehead, causes a diminished capacity for social emotions but leaves logical reasoning intact.

Researchers from USC, the University of Iowa, Harvard University and Caltech posed 50 hypothetical scenarios to six people whose ventromedial prefrontal cortices were damaged by strokes or tumors. Their responses were compared to those given by 12 people without brain damage and 12 others with damage in brain areas that regulate other emotions, such as fear.

...Joshua D. Greene, a Harvard psychologist not involved in the research, said the study showed that moral judgment was shaped by two brain systems — one focused on intuitive emotional responses and another that controlled cognition.

2008 Just the Numbers: Week 12

THE NUMBERS

Fred Thompson gained again in the week, with most of it coming from McCain on the bid side of the market. Clinton gained slightly from Edwards' loss.

The GOP side of the race widened slightly, with just over 2% falling off of the top three probability. The converse occurred on the Democratic side, where the top three picked up.

THE STRATEGIES

The strategy mentioned last week picked up about 3.8% in the week, before trading costs. If one thinks that the Thompson thing is a fling, then there is now an additional 10% there. I'm not sure he could raise the money he needs now, with others having gotten a head start.

Next PresidentPr (%)Chg Wk.bid-ask
CLINTON(H)23.7-0.110%
GIULIANI20010%
OBAMA18.42.48%
McCAIN12.13.114%
GORE7.50.49%
ROMNEY7.10.111%
EDWARDS4-250%
2007 Week 12: House passes budget calling for end to combat role by Fall '08; White House and Congress tussle over subpoenas in DOJ firings; Edwards announces wife's cancer no longer in remission.
GOP NomineePr (%)Chg Wk.bid-ask
GIULIANI40.50.41%
MCCAIN20.1-1.90%
ROMNEY16.50.43%
THOMPSON(F)10.13.18%
GINGRICH3.3-0.418%
HUCKABEE2.80.34%
HAGEL2.3030%
DEM NomineePr (%)Chg Wk.bid-ask
CLINTON472.12%
OBAMA29.4-0.35%
GORE10.70.37%
EDWARDS6.8-2.19%
RICHRDSN4.40.45%
BIDEN0.4-0.6n.m.
CLARK0.3-0.1n.m.
SenatePr (%)Chg Wk.bid-ask
DEM7727%
GOP17.51.531%
Next ExecutivePr (%)Chg Wk.bid-ask
DEM56.102%
GOP42.600%
OTH1.2-0.2n.m.


src: intrade.com; bid-ask are not points, but spread as a percentage of the bid.
IMPORTANT DISCLAIMER: this is just an informational note and not a solicitation or recommendation to buy or sell securities and there is no guarantee implied and people can lose all money on all investments. Numbers are believed to be correct, but do your own math and make your own conclusions or consult with an advisor before making any decisions.

Saturday, March 17, 2007

2008 Just the Numbers: Week 11

NEW TABLES, BOUNCE IN BIDS

The bid-offers have tightened in the week, which accounts for the large changes. Either that or there is a sampling bias associated with my practice of picking up these figures at week's end, when fewer bids are being made. The source prefers to do their charts on the offer (I've included new hyperlinks to them at the head of each table), but I prefer the bid.

BETTING AGAINST McCAIN?

That said, the widening of the bid-offer spread on the McCain in the Presidential contracts doesn't have an obvious explanation, as there wasn't especially thin volume. If fact, the regular size volume suggests that someone might be betting against McCain and driving the price down ...

GOP FIELD IS "OPENISH"

The GOP field is more open still than the democratic one, with 21% of the probability distribution outside the top three leaders. In contrast, the Dem field is more narrow, with 15% outside the top three.

EARLY RISKS DIFFERENT CHARACTER THAN LATER ON

Used to reading polls, people may think it is too early to think about these figures. However, there is arguably "smart" money to be made, potentially, by taking risks early, before races turn binary.

For instance, betting against this combo gains some 31% (before trading costs) perhaps by Super Tuesday, less than a year away on Feb 5: On the Democratic side, Gore, Edwards, Biden, Clark; on the Republican side, Hagel, Gingrich, Huckabee, and Brownback.

[n.b. refer to contract specification for details - contracts do not technically settle on Super Tuesday and unwinding trades before then would include paying the bid-offer spread, which is currently running at 0.1 for zero-bid candidates - or 0.8 for the eight candidates above, but may not guaranteed].


Next PresidentPr (%)Chg Wk.bid-ask
CLINTON(H)23.813.34%
GIULIANI2036%
OBAMA1615.924%
McCAIN9-14.3100%
GORE7.1-12.910%
ROMNEY7-0.511%
EDWARDS6615%
2007 Week 11: GOP regulars unhappy with field, so Fred Thompson percolates in week; Newt in infidelity admission; Obama/Clinton forced to pronounce on "immorality"; Plame testifies; Gonzales "takes full responsibility". Dodd announces; Hagel fails to announce at his announcement.
GOP NomineePr (%)Chg Wk.bid-ask
GIULIANI40.10.14%
MCCAIN22-23%
ROMNEY16.1-2.22%
THOMPSON(F)76.87%
HAGEL2.3-1.239%
GINGRICH3.7-0.816%
HUCKABEE2.50.116%
DEM NomineePr (%)Chg Wk.bid-ask
CLINTON44.90.70%
OBAMA29.7-0.12%
GORE10.4-1.12%
EDWARDS8.90.39%
RICHRDSN40.52%
BIDEN10n.m.
CLARK0.40n.m.
SenatePr (%)Chg Wk.bid-ask
DEM75212%
GOP16-450%
Next ExecutivePr (%)Chg Wk.bid-ask
DEM56.102%
GOP42.601%
OTH1.40n.m.

src: intrade.com; bid-ask are not points, but spread as a percentage of the bid.
IMPORTANT DISCLAIMER: this is just an informational note and not a solicitation or recommendation to buy or sell securities and there is no guarantee implied and people can lose all money on all investments. Numbers are believed to be correct, but do your own math and make your own conclusions or consult with an advisor before making any decisions.

Friday, March 16, 2007

The Supplemental War

It took a while, but against the backdrop of another $100+ Billion wartime "supplemental", the expansion of the standing army, and General Petreaus' recent re-upping of the surge strength, I dug about for a long while until I could compose this table.

The mis-management of Operation Iraqi Freedom has probably cost the nation billions more than if it had been handled properly.

Here is an interesting metric. The cost of the war in Iraq, if you include conservative estimates for rebuilding the army and military benefits, has probably gone past the sum of ALL costs associated with the "New Deal" welfare programs, what used be called "Aid to Families with Dependent Children" (AFDC under HHS supervision).

In other words, the entire history of "welfare" cost the US taxapayer just about as much as Bush's incompetence in executing the Iraqi effort.

The table below shows the total of Federal AND State expenditures, benefits and administration costs, from 1962 to 1996, when the law was changed. The total is $734 billion in 1996 dollars. (You can make your own back-of-the-envelop inflation from 1996 to 2003, when OIF started.)


Yr$ B
1962$3.7
1963$3.9
1964$4.3
1965$4.7
1966$4.9
1967$5.6
1968$6.8
1969$8.1
1970$19.1
1971$22.1
1972$25.2
1973$26.
1974$25.6
1975$27.2
1976$28.9
1977$28.9
1978$27.9
1979$26.2
1980$26.
1981$25.5
1982$24.
1983$24.4
1984$24.5
1985$24.6
1986$25.4
1987$25.6
1988$25.3
1989$24.9
1990$25.6
1991$26.5
1992$28.
1993$27.4
1994$27.6
1995$26.3
1996$23.7
Total:$734.3

Monday, March 12, 2007

When Theories Fail

Zakaria throws down the gauntlet to various development economics orthodoxies:

It might be time to admit that we really don't understand China. The country simply does not conform to our most basic beliefs about what makes nations grow.

Hernando de Soto, the Peruvian scholar, has argued persuasively that clear and strong property rights are the prerequisite for economic growth. Except that China, the fastest-growing country in human history, has an extremely unclear and weak system of property rights.

Alan Greenspan has argued that the rule of law is the linchpin of market economics. Except that China has a patchy set of laws, unevenly enforced.

The Washington Consensus that the World Bank and the IMF have peddled across the globe claims that if currencies don't float freely, they will produce huge distortions in the economy. China has declined that advice and yet prospers.

So, instead of learning from facts and revising theory, we assume that the facts are wrong, that China is one grand charade.