Friday, December 12, 2008

Quote for The Day

The latest CDS salvo had me go read Arnold Kling's testimony from earlier this week (previously, I just went on what I heard, what was spoken for the committee).

Rather than more on CDS today, here is some more confirming evidence that I, a complete outsider, have the right read on key issues at the GSEs:

When I was at Freddie Mac, there was hardly any gap between the suits and the geeks. The Foster-Van Order model of mortgage default was ingrained in the corporate culture. The CEO, CFO, and other key executives understood this model and its implication that mortgage defaults would be much higher for mortgages with low down payments. Moreover, the suits bought into the idea of using a stress test to set capital requirements. Using a stress test methodology, in which mortgages are evaluated according to how well they would survive a downturn in house prices, the capital required to back mortgages with low down payments is prohibitively high.

When a new CEO came to Freddie Mac in 2003 (several years after I had left), a gap apparently opened up between the suits and the geeks. Warnings issued by the Chief Risk Officer and others about low down payment mortgages were ignored by the CEO.


An organizational failure requires an organizational re-design. It doesn't require a ... a whole lot of hand wringing about everything else.

Invincible Wall Street, Part II

THERE IS NO BOOKEND FOR THIS TALE, JUST NEW CHAPTERS

  • Citibank will pay $7 billion to settle the massive auction-rate securities debacle.

  • Fidelitys' crew will settle Wall Street's version of pay-to-play (or plug-'n-play or whatever).

  • Last, a fraud scheme so vast that the SEC called it "epic" and Ponzi himself would have either blushed or have had his proudest moment to date. Made possible by complete faith in a little audit group in the middle of nowhere and belied by returns so statistically improbable that Mendel would have grinned.


Madoff’s auditor, Friehling & Horowitz, operated from a 13-by-18-foot office in Rockland County, New York. Vos had an investigator stake out the office [!!! I missed that in due-diligence class]. A call to the New City, New York, office of Friehling & Horowitz after business hours wasn’t returned. (Bloomberg)


Update: CNBC is asking about fraudulent conveyance. I doubt there is such a thing for a fraud itself, right? That's like asking, "Was the fraud conducted fairly?" Who knows, though. It's just crazy enough to be possible...

Update2: split-strike is a fancy, modified buy-write strategy. They promise "daily liquidity".

Update3: Oh, what a list of investors. Every no-name auditor in the industry can expect the phone to be ringing off the hook in the next week.

Update4: Askia says that OEX options market couldn't handle $13 billion ... is that true? It does appear to be. Today's open interest of 188188 appears to suggest a size of just under $8 billion, far in excess of whatever the daily volume would be...

Thursday, December 11, 2008

CDS - To Be or Not To Be

John Dizard throws in the towel on credit default swaps (CDS). Felix Salmon is not ready to yet. Arnold Kling sees a vindication of a negative (prosecutorial) view.

Here's 2-cents. (This is a long post, but not complex):

Dizard weighs in on three points, "capital raising", "price discovery", and "risk mangement tool":

1. Capital Raising


The 'response' to Dizard's points is in three parts, complicated by the fact that CDS technology has been used in a variety of ways, so broad-brush is no good.

1(a) Balance-sheet management, credit intermediation, structured credits

'Capital raising' may mean the use of CDS in BISTRO-like products and synthetic products that transferred risk and may or may not have freed up risk-capital.

To the best I understand it, the writers of protection in this "structured market" are not the ones who are putting up collateral, now. The buyers put in upfront collateral, as best I know (and what I know about that is very limited).

There may have been additional trading of CDS outside of these structured products, yet related to them, but that is analytically separate - this is just about the products themselves.

It's not at all clear that the goal of credit inter mediation and build-to-suit credit is not worthy. They seem like fairly natural innovations, a step in the conceptual the evolution of risk-sharing and risk-management technologies. Before rejecting an innovation, I'd like to be certain that the risks were either practically or theoretically unmanageable. If there is evidence one way or the other in the current carnage, it needs to be sorted out thoroughly, not summarily.


1(b) Sharing a 'AAA' credit rating via CDS - a "naked" loan portfolio

If he means 'capital raising' to refer to something else, like AIG's (naked?) "regulatory capital CDS" contracts, then that is a different and interesting point. Should the financial strength behind a promise to pay be "tied up" in increasing (decreasing) amounts of capital, as dictated by an illiquid market? If a firm's exposure were just a loan gone bad, there would be no mark-to-market capital requirement. In that case, only a credit event would cause capital "to be posted", "violently" and all 'at once'. Is 'the system' more or less stable for having a seemless capital requirement all along the way, based on market-based assessments of the likelihood of loss?

To me, part of the answer to that lies in whether the CDS market is exaggerating moves in the cash market. So far, it doesn't look like it is. The two appear to be equally bad in tandem. Also, the illiquid, non-traded cash market does move in discreet intervals to require "collateral". As business conditions worsen, lenders' loan covenants get violated. You do not have to wait for "bankruptcy" for significant credit events (compare also ratings downgrades/upgrades). So, in a sense, there has always been a bit of mark-to-market of outstanding credit risk, in the form of demanding "collateral" or proof of ability to pay. The capital impact of credit loans gone bad also occurs explicitly in the loan-loss reserve. If a bank has bad loans, it would be required to estimate the likelihood of those loans being repaid. It takes a non-cash hit to capital, to the extent that the outlook worsens. Is that outlook better estimated by company managements than by CDS market prices?

Do market prices move ahead and faster than "business conditions"? Probably. Does that mean CDS are defunct? That's unclear. You'd have to posit that CDS market prices overshoot and have a (negative) business conditions feedback, more than cash bond/note prices do, right?

Is it as bad as Jesse Eissinger reports, with Bill Demchak agreed (see very end of article), that we have 24- year olds determining the price of things, introducing ridiculous levels of balance-sheet volatility? Maybe, maybe not. I'm not convinced yet which state of affairs is better/worse: illiquid unknowns (opaquely fragile balance sheets) or illiquid knowns (transparently fragile balance sheets - "frozen" in Dizard's terminology).

Last, in a broader view, you can argue that the capital requirements related to the credit risk inherent in a long CDS are the same or less than a loan. If I don't miss my guess, these credit exposures probably graph about the same, over time, as does a vanilla interest rate swap. The fact that the market for CDS might suddenly become illiquid means that VAR is not the only measure, but that notional limits are still a good idea, too.

1(c) Short-term trading of a "view" on credit

If capital raising means just the collateral posted by hedge-funds and dealers swapping views on the direction of this or that credit, then consider this: those risk-transfers are a zero-sum game. If collateral is not also a zero-sum game, then perhaps that needs to be explored, as Felix says. Also, if this is truly short-term trading, then one suspects that these trades unwind/terminate, even at abusive, illiquid prices, rather than being the cause of a sustained, significant, non-economic build-up in collateral.


2. Price Discovery

Dizard says:

But CDS are derivative instruments, whose price is "discovered" these days as a function of equity volatility, since buying equity puts is one way to dynamically hedge the illiquid legacy books.

So CDS dealer sales of Citigroup equity through derivatives means higher equity volatility, then higher CDS spreads, leading to more margin calls, leading to more sales of bank stocks . . . This has become a system-wide tail-swallowing exercise in lunacy
The second part first. This seems to be a variation of the age-old theme that derivatives increase the volatility of the spot/underlying markets. In this case, the author suggests more than that, that there is also a destructive feedback loop, an inherent instability created.

First, I may be completely wrong, but I don't think you dynamically hedge (long) CDS using equity puts, in the normal sense of a dynamic, parametric hedge. Buying a put on the equity is a (costly) and sufficient hedge. As the probability of default goes to one, the put value goes up. You are covered. If someone is buying and selling partial hedges as part of an overall strategy, that seems to require another name.

The market maker who bought/sold the equity put might need to delta-hedge in the equity market. To the extent that they are using a market-maker exception to short naked, that's a potential problem. To the extent that non-market makers are restricted to legal shorts, it's not an obvious problem.

Apart from an interesting and important consideration, the sum of this problem seems to be that "price discovery" at or around high default likelihood is problematic. D'oh! The notion that equity volatility is high near times of default is ... not particularly alarming, either. It doesn't have to be high default likelihood, either. It could just be conditions in which no one wants to bear the risk of credit or too few the financing/capacity to take advantage of the price-opportunities created by peak risk-aversion or market illiquidity.


3. Risk Management Tool

Dizard notes:
A credit default swap is a very different creature than the traded equity of a "reference entity". CDS cover only one on-off risk, that is, default on reference obligations. So in the airless world of ideal models, CDS values are better considered as binomial probability distributions, rather than as the continuous probability distributions that are closer approximations of equity values.
One could also conjecture that what we are seeing is a dual-pricing regime for CDS, not a bi-modal distribution. One type of pricing for high probability risk of default, when "replication protection" is paramount (for hedging), and another for moderate to low default risk, when replication/no-arbitrage is less important.

Were this a wild ride, you'd expect the CDS spreads to be really, really wide compared to the cash bond spreads, right? At least I would, as all the "weird" theoretical assumptions got violated and knocked risk-models around, etc. Well, so far as I can tell, the CDS are trading at or near the cash bond prices (sometimes even inside the cash spreads).

The reg-cap arbitrage problem at AIG, in my view, could be solved with notional limits, at a minimum, rather than relying on VaR, or sophisticated peak credit-risk calculations. This reflects the fact that a seller of protection (long the credit risk) could end up with a de facto loan. You need capital to cover that "worst case" scenario. Of course, the caliber of the top leadership at AIG at the time appears to be such that that was unknowable...

I confess I do not understand this paragraph, so I cannot comment, although I feel I should be able to, eventually. First pass, it looks like this is a way of estimating some of the parameters of the pricing models in use, and I don't understand its applicability:

When implied probability of default, and equity volatility, are relatively low, you can do some seemingly plausible regression analyses to fit the series. But at high levels of default risk and equity volatility, if you hedge the one with the other you get frantic, self-defeating activity.


The point about whether an on-off contract is the best way to trade continuous views about credit spreads is one worth thinking through. Why doesn't the market just trade put/call options, with various strikes, on a variety of credit spreads, for instance? What's the particular allure of the CDS construct?

update:

For those like Arnold Kling looking for a fuller theoretical understanding of CDS, here is Hull & White, available online (not to difficult for those who already have an understanding of options pricing theory):

VALUING CREDIT DEFAULT SWAPS I: NO COUNTERPARTY DEFAULT RISK (link: http://tinyurl.com/3dkufk)

VALUING CREDIT DEFAULT SWAPS II: MODELING DEFAULT CORRELATIONS (link: http://tinyurl.com/57y45p)

Here is the math for backing implied default probabilities for simple contracts.

Quote for the Day

No regulation or law forced banks or the GSEs to acquire loans that were so risky they imperiled the safety and soundness of the institutions. The acquisition of such loans was a business judgment made by management and the boards of directors.

- Franklin Raines, former CEO FannieMae, yesterday's testimony

Raines testimony is fascinating. His grasp of the issues seems to far exceed those of his peers at the table.

More to say later on (I'm reviewing data, sorting out Christmas presents, and much else besides!).

Tuesday, December 9, 2008

Pinto: 8 Million Defaults

Overall cumulative default rates (note the sea-change starting with the 2004 vintage):

In the bleakest testimony yet heard, Edward Pinto, former Chief Credit Officer of FannieMae, suggests that the magnitude of the problem, on his figures, is larger than non-Roubini estimates.

Mitigation must be forthcoming ... we've lost a lot of time already.

It's not just loan modifications, at the margin.

It's a restructuring of all or most mortgage debt, quite possibly, to allow for price falls without the market becoming seriously illiquid.

It's also a change in the legal relationships among lender, borrower, servicers, brokers, and investors, in whatever type of products, products that may also get new transparency requirements, at a minimum.

Fannie Freddie - First Pass

It was demand pull, not supply push.

The creation of slik purses out of sow's ears had created a credit 'mania' on Wall Street, an insatiable demand for 'product', so much so that large brokerage houses felt the need to have their own, captive sub-prime origination units.

There were other factors, but this, more than the others, is explanatory. It explains almost all the pressures created by the demand for volume.

If anything, I'd be looking for evidence that HUD goals raised in the 2005 period and onward, like so much else, followed or abetted the mania, not that they were the cause of it.

Today's hearing details here.

Quote for the Day 2

Arnold Kling, who doesn't believe in securitization does not believe securitization is necessary:


it turns out that when a high-risk loan has been laundered by Wall Street, it can come back into the banking system in the form of a AAA-rated security tranche.

Quote for the Day

"Reality exceeded my imagination." - Daniel Mudd, 2003-2008, FannieMae CEO

***

"For two years, Mr. Mudd operated without a permanent chief risk officer to guard against unhealthy hazards." - New York Times, Oct 5, 2008

How Does Wall Street Trade "Recovery Rates"?

Over at Alphaville, Sam Jones writes:

A rising default rate is one thing. A rising default rate with a falling recovery rate is quite another.
This raises the question of whether Wall Streeters put yet another gun to their own head.

The research, to the extent I know it - not even close to state-of-the-art any longer, is that there is a very significant part of recovery rates that are "systemic" and that they are, in fact, quite pro-cyclical.

So, yes, in a downturn, defaults and lower recovery rates aren't oddball.

Now, has Moody's published their model, so that we can see just how they are doing with this? S&P? Fitch?

Make you a bet: they will stop rating paper before they agree to share their model with the inquiring public, who depend so obviously on the deft execution of their trade.

Thain and the Gravy Train

BAC share prices has lagged JPM since its "Merrill weekend"...

The Merrill Board, who haven't missed a full dividend payment throughout the entire Merrill saga, are wimps for not giving Thain his due. He should have gotten "Grasso money", afterall. He got BAC to overpay by maybe $15/shr (if not more). If Thain recovered 2.5% of that in compensation, it would be $600 million.

The Merrill Board should have paid him, just to send a reinforcing message to Lewis how things are done downtown, right?

Meanwhile, the real question is how much CEO Lewis is going to get this year (and next), eh? Have a look at how he's arguably trashed his shareholders, in the chart above, by bending too far to scoop up toxins... while keeping an eye on how much the top-heavy riches of Merrill's magically endless sugar plums will come his way?

Someone (Nassim Taleb?) forgot to tell him the gold is cursed, maybe...

Monday, December 8, 2008

"No Soup For You!!!"

The strange tale of the Great Port Authority's dry-well. (h/t Alea)

Excelsior Risk Management

Paul K has the video of Nassum Taleb on Charlie Rose.

From the talk, I'd guess that Taleb over-estimates the momentum for change.

It still amazes me just how much risk management topics are popularized or topical. I never pegged this field as one with "legs", as they say. That's neither here nor there, though.

Just as a matter of fact, the notion that financial market distributions are non-Gaussian has been around since the 1960s. It's not clear how Nassum intends to actually manage/run a firm's risk, in the case of non-finite variances ... (perhaps I should read the book? D'oh!).

VaR, even at 2-sigmas, was never meant to be a catch-all risk measure, was it? Accordingly, it just sounds like firms have another round of risk measurement to go through and that folks, like RiskMetrics, have been over-priced for a long time now (and out of the public view - who called them to Washington to testify, eh?). No one complains about their Executive salaries, the amount they collected from Wall Street for what so many are saying are worthless measures.

CMOs blew up. The still exist, today. CDOs blew up. The will exist tomorrow. The products will change and maybe the investor classes will get more targeted. Did you notice that the latest Moody's CDO model - at least in the advert I glanced at yesterday, incorporates i-th-to-default modeling? That suggests that people may be getting smarter about the credit risks they agree to sell short.

There will continue to be a market for "everyday risk" asset-classes. As John Templeton once said, "What are you going to do? Sell everything and wait for the world to end?"

What we do not know is whether those who leverage "everyday risk" will ... "endure", for lack of a better phrase. You'd think not, but you might be wrong.

Sunday, December 7, 2008

This Week In Markets History

Didn't want to miss this one, since we get a new record (or two!) almost every week now:


Dec 3rd, FT

The Markit iTraxx Crossover index rose above 1,000 basis points for the first time since it was created in 2004, ...

The index, composed of 50 mostly junk-rated companies in Europe, rose 60 basis points to highs of about 1,020bp, according to Markit, the data provider.

It was trading at about 700bp, or a cost of €700,000 to insure €10m of debt annually against default over five years, on November 1. Before the credit crunch it was below 200bp.




Also, Gold prices on Comex were in rare - very rare - backwardation on the 2nd and 3rd. [I'm looking for a chart/data...]

Invincible Wall Street


PUBLISH OR PERISH?

Remember Arther Andersen, the great accounting firm, built up by years of hard work in a competitive environment? Member of the "Big Seven" and then the "Big Five"?

Well, once they lost public trust, Andersen was brutally punished, as their clients had to leave them.

So why are the ratings agencies, Moody's, S&P, and Fitch all ... doing business as usual?

Sure, the Justice department got involved because AA's Dallas office was exceptionally naughty (in comparison to other auditing fiascoes), but is the business of public accounting - are the goals of public accounting - really that much different than rating agencies?

At least with GAAP, there is a FASB and a public agency, like the SEC, who are subject to public pressure and provide a visible process.

Well, Bloomberg filed a FOIA request on the Fed, but what about the ratings agencies? At a minimum, they should publish their CDO model, their current and historical model assumptions, and their estimation methodology/data to the public, right?